Posted by: 愛撫 | 05/03/08

Album review: Eiko Shimamiya – Hikarinadeshiko

Reviewed close to a full month late, you can find Aibu’s take on Eiko Shimamiya’s second Geneon full-length below the cut.

Eiko Shimamiya (島みやえい子) – ひかりなでしこ (Hikarinadeshiko) (2008, Geneon)

HikaNade album cover


1. Introduction

2. ひかりなでしこ

3. all alone


5. 観覧車 (Kanransha)

6. scheherazade

7. 奈落の花 (Naraku no Hana)

8. 青い果実 (Aoi Kajitsu)


10. あすなろの木 (Asunaro no Ki)

11. 十四の月 (Garasu no Tsuki)

12. ハルミチル (Haru Michiru)

13. 愛のうた (Ai no Uta)

The review:

Eiko Shimamiya’s latest album Hikarinadeshiko has the dubious distinction of having what has to be the most controversial tracklisting in I’ve history: 6 of the album’s 13 tracks were composed and arranged by producers outside of I’ve, and of the I’ve songs, only 3 are truly exclusive to the album in any way: last year’s standout single Naraku no Hana as well as its rancid, debatably I’ve B-side FLOW are both present, as is the largely forgettable Higurashi no Naku Koro ni B-side ‘all alone’ and 2 selections from Eiko’s now-ancient Comiket-exclusive EP Ozone (Garasu no Tsuki and Ai no Uta, the latter providing C.G mix’s sole contribution to the sad mess of an album).

But, really, original release or not, Hikarinadeshiko sucks. I don’t want to mince words for fear of giving this album more time than it’s worth, hence the abruptness in simply declaring suckiness right off the bat. But, one might wonder, what precisely makes this album suck so god-damned bad?

Well, first off, there’s the simple fact that it’s an Eiko Shimamiya album first and an I’ve album maybe seven-hundredth. Not meaning to knock Shimamiya, she’s a talented singer and competent lyricist far as I can tell from song translations, and her singles with Tomoyuki Nakazawa made me squeal like a schoolgirl… But this does not, in any way, mean that she is qualified to dictate the predominant direction of an album. Her previous album, O, succeeded because control was handed over to I’ve’s immensely talented arrangers (OK, and SORMA No.1) and the songs were able to run free as the kind of atmospheric long-form compositions Eiko’s eerie voice lends itself so well to instead of being locked into the blandness of verse-chorus-verse.

Then, after seeing that she had made a brilliant album by doing one thing, Eiko decided to go “fuck this shit” and made herself the star of its follow-up. Hikarinadeshiko is every bit a product of Shimamiya’s tedious singer/songwriter indulgences, a desert of indistinct ballads where the extraneous background music ranges from utterly hideous at worst (Maiko Iuchi’s loungecore nightmare Haru Michiru, for one) to blandly inoffensive at best (Aoi Kajitsu is halfway decent despite its non-I’ve production: in my business, that’s what we call a fluke), barren landscape pockmarked by a few glistening oases (Naraku no Hana, mostly, but scheherazade is sort of funky) but you’d need a superhuman resistance to awfulness to not just give up long before you reach one of those shiny little ponds. It took this reviewer some 4 tries to get through this waste of perfectly good almost-pure polycarbonate plastic, and I only bothered trying for my blog’s sake: I see no reason why anyone would voluntarily put themselves through that experience without a good fucking reason.

Second, it lacks flow or continuity on the basest of levels. The new tracks and the previously-released ones go together like peanut butter and trout, except the trout (new shit) is horrible and infected with all sorts of diseases while the peanut butter (Naraku no Hana) is so delicious it makes you wish more than anything that there were more of it to cover up the taste of that vile, decaying old fish with. But even if there were more peanut butter, the songs still don’t mesh – they’re artlessly stuck one after another seemingly without a single thought given to the order and flow, with hideous mistakes such as putting the epic album-closer Naraku no Hana stuck smack dab in the middle, including Kanransha on the album, and making the first real song on the album a seemingly endless ballad that inspires nothing more than the desire to not listen to the rest all very much present.

But the final flaw is, as I’ve spent so much time saying already, the songs aren’t good, and if they are you’ve heard them elsewhere. Aside from scheherazade, maybe, but one song does not in any way justify the import pricing an album like Hikarinadeshiko commands. If you want Eiko Shimamiya, she has a number of other quality releases to choose from, none of which include Haru Michiru. If you want to hear a full album of I’ve at their best, Mami Kawada’s SAVIA is all that and a bag of chips. Unless you really, really want to waste your money (or hard drive space, for all the pirates out there) on an album that could suck a proverbial golf ball out of an equally proverbial garden hose, I just can’t find any way to recommend Hikarinadeshiko.

However, after all that, there’s one thing I still have to give the album credit for: while all insanity on this blog had previously been the sole domain of founder/reviewer Aibu (aka me), it seems that after Kanransha’s relentless badness, newshound/main-poster-until-I-get-my-act-together Hikaruhoshi has finally found his chance to snap. Hooray for Hikarinadeshiko, eh?



  1. I can’t really blame the suckiness on Eiko. According to Kotoko, most of the songs are pre-composed & arranged and they just have to fill in the blanks, but this can’t be used to excuse this album. Of course I knew from the beginning that the album wasn’t going to be that great considering the non-I’ve staff working on it. All in all, O was waaaay better than Hikarinadeshiko.

  2. Just when I thought ‘Ai no Uta’ is one amazing song, it actually exists back some years ago.
    I really love this song.

  3. What, this is supposed to be a review? It seemed more of an rant to me.

    Personally, SAVIA gets on my nerves pretty badly whereas Hikarinadeshiko is goddamn enjoyable to listen to.
    Yes, I skip Harumichiru, but is that a reason for a resolution such as ‘the whole album sucks’?

  4. Niwa, I have a question for you. Now, you don’t have to answer if you don’t want to, but I think that it would really help me understand why you feel so strongly about Hikarinadeshiko being an ‘enjoyable’ album.

    You’ve been in an elevator before, right? Entering on the bottom floor, going to the top, trying not to choke to death on the thick scent of the perfume the woman next to you is wearing… All of that. You’ve done it, I’m pretty sure you have. And, while you were doing this, did you happen to really enjoy the music playing? Like, really get into the elevator music. Ever happen to you?

  5. I just got my ears on this album and it DOES suck! (REALLY BADLY) Sheherazade is enjoyable and quite nice, but it doesn’t sound like I’ve. Wait a second, it’s not I’ve! *pukes* Naraku no hana is AWESOME, but it’s not property of this album…

    The cover is (slightly) nice though…

  6. I am almost 3 years late in this, but I discovered Eiko’s songs just a few months ago. Maybe I’m one of those “few” who enjoyed this album. I didn’t like all of the songs, but the great ones made up for the bad ones. I don’t know about others, but I’m sure that there are albums MUCH worse than this. As much as I’ve read from the review, they are simply rants but no justifications why the album suck hard. What are the reason it’s freaking bad? Because some of them weren’t produced by I’ve? Because they lack continuity or flow? I won’t accept those as reasons. Actually 2 of my top favorites from Eiko are in this album (Juuyon no tsuki and Ai no Uta) The word HIDEOUS to describe this album is just too much. It’s alright though, everyone has their own opinions and everyone has the right to voice out what the think. I respect you opinion. But no matter what you say (in case you reply) you won’t ever change what I feel about this album or for Eiko. For me she’s the best in I’ve and one of my favorite musicians on the face of the Earth.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: